On Secularization and Genuine Christian Education
Written by Niel Nielson on February 4th, 2010The Winter 2010 issue of Christian Scholar’s Review includes an article titled “A Slippery Slope to Secularization? An Empirical Analysis of the Council for Christian Colleges and Universities,” by Samuel Joeckel and Thomas Chesnes, both on the faculty of Palm Beach Atlantic University. The article presents the authors’ analysis of results of a 2007 survey of 1,900 CCCU faculty, concluding that “these institutions are hardly descending a slippery slope to secularization.” They go on to argue that “overzealous vigilance against secularization proves counterproductive” to the appropriate ethos and aims of higher education.
The authors claim that their data “suggest that faculty at CCCU institutions are firmly committed to Christian higher education,” basing that judgment, at least in part, on the following responses:
• 98% strongly or somewhat agree with “My college/university should maintain its Christian identity”;
• 94% strongly or somewhat agree with “I have a good idea of what is meant by the phrase, ‘the integration of faith and learning’”;
• 84% strongly or somewhat agree with “It is not difficult for me to integrate faith and learning in my discipline.”
They also claim that their data “suggest that CCCU institutions are places where faith is nurtured and strengthened,” with 79% reporting that, “as a result of the time spent at their college/university, their faith has either become much or somewhat stronger” (sic).
So here is their conclusion:
Based upon our data, we conclude that the dangers of secularization, insofar as they apply to the CCCU, have been overstated. Survey participants overwhelmingly endorse the Christian identity of their institutions; participants also understand and practice the integration of faith and learning.
Finally, they quote approvingly an author who refers to “the myth of declension” which “has cramped our thinking and narrowed our reflection on the nature and character of Christian scholarship.” (Rodney Sawatsky, Scholarship and Christian Faith: Enlarging the Conversation)
I can only begin to scratch the surface of the serious and complex issues which the authors gloss over in their effort to convince us that everything is just fine in Christian higher education — and that any who claim otherwise should be characterized as over-vigilant, hyper-conservative, closed-minded indoctrinators. . . in other words, the real problem. Click to continue »